Rules are made to be followed, except where logic dictates otherwise

15 Jun

Rules.  I’m a firm believer in rules.  But there’s always an exception to the rules, and in this case that exception is REVOLUTION!

Now don’t get me wrong.  I’m not some crazed Libertarian walking around half-cocked about the societal limitations placed on us by ‘Big Government’ for the greater good.  Quite the contrary.

I’m the guy driving down the freeway, waiting for the solid line to change to dotted so I can enter the exit lane.  Even when the exit lane is empty and my lane is bumper-to-bumper traffic.  And I’m the guy cursing the bastards who are prematurely cutting across said solid line and zipping past me, making it harder for me to legally enter the lane once the line is dotted.

Yes, I’m that anal about rules.  The question shouldn’t be, “Is anal-retentive hyphenated?”  It should be, “Is anal-retentive hyphenated, and if so, is it an em dash or an en dash?”

(It’s en dash.  The em dash should be stricken from the English language and our memories.  It is an abomination.)

These are important distinctions to maintain if society isn’t going to crumble into a cannibal apocalypse.

(Read Lord of the Flies if you don’t believe me – all that unpleasantness started over the misuse of the possessive apostrophe with regards to a conch shell.)

For example, take the instruction, “Write your answers on the form below.”  That means cursive, not printed.  Or so a teacher once told my class after a logic test where we’d all printed, and therefore failed.

Now before you roll your eyes, imagine if that instruction had read, “Print your answers on the form below.”  Now you’re in the middle of it.  Does the instruction mean block print by hand, or does it mean take the form, put it in a printer, generate a document with the answers in the correct location, and then print those answers on the form, all while hoping you put the form in facing the right way because you can’t remember if the printer prints on the top face or bottom face of the sheet of paper in the tray and oh God do you have another copy of the form?

You can interpret it either way, which is why I prefer my rules to be clear.  And it saves a lot of arguing with the instructor about why your answer shouldn’t have been marked wrong when you get the graded exam back.

Here’s another example of a stupid rule.  It is, not surprisingly, a punctuation rule.

The sign read, “STOP,” so Marlowe, being a stickler for rules, stopped.

Now, I see that and quite naturally think the sign reads:


Why?  Because the ‘,’ is inside the freaking quotes!  But we know damn well there is no comma on that stop sign! (Or do we? Maybe this sign was a misprint? But that seems unlikely, and as it is my example, I say it doesn’t.)

Here’s how that sentence should read (and I am led to believe the British actually do it this way, so there may be hope yet):

The sign read, “STOP”, so Marlowe, being a stickler for rules, stopped.

(Or, as the English would print it: The sign read, ‘STOP’, so Marlowe, being a stickler for rules, stopped.  So they almost get it right.)

Seems perfectly reasonable, right?  Logic dictates, to quote Mr. Spock, that the quotes should surround the content of the sign and nothing else.  But then ‘Captain Kirk’, (oh, excuse me, ‘Captain Kirk,’) the overzealous, clapped-out English teacher circles my logical use of the comma and writes a ‘-5‘ next to it in bright red.  Over the course of the semester, where I heedlessly continued to follow the logical path with respect to comma placement and quotes, he started returning my assignments with little notes too:

“-5 Stop doing that.”

“Knock it off. -5”

“Are you by any chance dyslexic too? 1-”

“Wrong. -5”

“Wrong! -10!”

“Goddammit, your doing this on purpose!!! -50!” (And don’t think I didn’t find that misuse of ‘your’ ironic.  Or that he found it evenly remotely ironic when pointed out to him.)

“You will never amount to anything if you don’t start placing the commas appropriately.”

“I hate you and want you to die, you comma-misusing fuck.”

That left quite an impression on this impressionable fifth grader, let me tell you, a mental scar that was not softened by ‘Captain Kirk’s’ (whoa now THAT is awkward punctuation!) forcible removal by administrators from the school just moments ahead of an angry mob of parents.

Which brings me back to revolution.  We need to seize this language and take it back from the anal-retentives who insist we blindly follow stupid rules about commas and quotes.

We need to stop, the insanity!


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

One response to “Rules are made to be followed, except where logic dictates otherwise

  1. mchaos

    23 June 2011 at 9:14 pm

    Punctuation saves lives.

    Let’s eat, Grandma.


    Let’s eat Grandma.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: